Censorship in communist systems

Nature

Despite the claim of communism to be fully democratic and to be working with the wholehearted support of the people, communist governments still feel the need to suppress any political and ideological dissent from the standard party line. All media is subject to censorship; it may be confiscated and banned if it does not conform, and those responsible may be arrested. The gap left by the absence of free expression is filled with government propaganda and official information aimed at total indoctrination. Non-political matters such as scientific theory and art forms may also be censored or trimmed to conform with party policy, which may be unimaginative and anti-innovative. Effective censorship requires domestic intelligence surveillance, which may be aided by informants, and may give rise to underground and subversive measures. This situation encourages foreign influence and foreign propaganda (usually put out by radio broadcast) which may be inflammatory and cause international conflict. The current policy of "glasnost" in the former Soviet Union is an attempt to counter the most dangerous tendencies of decades of censorship, but the new policy itself illuminates the fact that the citizenry's responses, even to when and how they may dissent, are controlled by the party.

Background

Censorship in communist systems gained global attention during the early 20th century, particularly following the Russian Revolution and the establishment of the Soviet Union. International awareness intensified during the Cold War, as reports of suppressed dissent, restricted media, and controlled artistic expression emerged from Eastern Bloc countries and China. The problem’s significance became widely recognized through the testimonies of dissidents, samizdat literature, and international human rights campaigns, highlighting its pervasive impact on information flow and societal development.

Incidence

In 1983 in China, for example, one magazine was suppressed, and two key persons were purged from the 'People's daily' because that newspaper had suggested that the Chinese might be 'alienated' in their own society.

Claim

Censorship in communist systems is a grave and urgent problem that undermines basic human rights and stifles the free exchange of ideas. By silencing dissent and controlling information, these regimes perpetuate oppression, hinder progress, and deny citizens the ability to think and speak freely. Such censorship not only erodes individual autonomy but also damages society as a whole, making it a critical issue that demands global attention and condemnation.

Counter-claim

Censorship in communist systems is vastly overstated as a problem. In reality, it serves to maintain social harmony and prevent the spread of harmful misinformation. Many societies function smoothly with such controls, prioritizing collective well-being over unchecked individual expression. The West’s obsession with “freedom of speech” ignores the benefits of stability and unity. Frankly, concerns about censorship in these systems are exaggerated and not a significant issue in the grand scheme of governance.