1. World problems
  2. Protectionism in the air transportation industry

Protectionism in the air transportation industry

Nature

On most routes, the civil aviation market is apportioned by bilateral agreements between countries designating specific carriers on particular routes and the frequency of the service. Some developing countries also use bilateral agreements to control the number of flights and passengers that a foreign airline may fly to or from their territories to protect their own, much smaller, national airlines from competition from airlines of developed countries. At the non-governmental level, air fares are agreed upon in tariff conferences of the International Air Transport Association (IATA), subject to the approval of the governments concerned. Despite bilateral agreements and other controls, it would seem that the influence of IATA on the setting of tariffs has been declining in recent years, notably due to a policy of reduced intervention by the United Nations. Almost every country reserves for its national airline all flights wholly within its territory. Some regulations and practices in both developed and developing countries frequently favour local airline companies. Foreign airlines may be subject to differential taxation, such as higher business and sales taxes. National carriers are also frequently granted preferential airport user rates on such items as landing fees and hangar and parking charges. Furthermore, national carriers are accorded preference in airport facilities and services. Ground handling services may be the monopoly of the national airline or some other designated national company. The access of foreign airline companies to automated reservation and ticketing systems may be limited.

Background

Protectionism in the air transportation industry emerged as a significant global concern in the mid-20th century, when postwar international agreements, such as the 1944 Chicago Convention, institutionalized national control over airspace and market access. As commercial aviation expanded, restrictive bilateral air service agreements and state subsidies drew increasing scrutiny from the 1970s onward, with debates intensifying over their impact on competition, efficiency, and international connectivity. This issue remains central amid ongoing liberalization efforts and evolving geopolitical tensions.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Incidence

Protectionism in the air transportation industry remains a significant global issue, with numerous countries imposing restrictions on foreign airlines through ownership limits, route controls, and subsidies to national carriers. These measures distort competition, limit market access, and hinder the development of a truly open international aviation market. The persistence of such policies affects both developed and developing regions, impacting connectivity, ticket prices, and the efficiency of global air travel networks.
In 2023, the European Union and the United States clashed over subsidies provided to their respective aircraft manufacturers, Airbus and Boeing, leading to retaliatory tariffs and renewed scrutiny of protectionist practices in the aviation sector.
This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Claim

Protectionism in the air transportation industry is a critical problem that stifles competition, inflates ticket prices, and limits consumer choice. By shielding national carriers from global rivals, governments undermine efficiency and innovation, ultimately hurting travelers and economies alike. In an interconnected world, such outdated policies are indefensible and directly impede progress. It’s time to dismantle these barriers and allow the aviation sector to truly soar for the benefit of all.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Counter-claim

Protectionism in the air transportation industry is vastly overstated as a problem. Airlines already operate in a highly regulated, safety-driven environment where national interests and security are paramount. The supposed harms of protectionism pale in comparison to the benefits of stable jobs, reliable service, and national oversight. Frankly, there are far more pressing issues in aviation than worrying about a little government intervention to protect domestic carriers and maintain essential connectivity.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Broader

Strategy

Value

Protectionism
Yet to rate

SDG

Sustainable Development Goal #9: Industry, Innovation and InfrastructureSustainable Development Goal #10: Reduced InequalitySustainable Development Goal #12: Responsible Consumption and Production

Metadata

Database
World problems
Type
(D) Detailed problems
Biological classification
N/A
Subject
  • Industry » Industry
  • Transportation, telecommunications » Aviation
  • Transportation, telecommunications » Transportation
  • Content quality
    Presentable
     Presentable
    Language
    English
    1A4N
    D7132
    DOCID
    11471320
    D7NID
    151719
    Editing link
    Official link
    Last update
    Oct 4, 2020