1. World problems
  2. Non-viability of small states and territories

Non-viability of small states and territories

Nature

There are a large number of states and territories which can be categorized as 'small'. Many of the difficulties of most small states and territories are directly related to underdevelopment in general; lack of resources, inadequate cadres, illiteracy, etc. In addition, many handicaps of the small territories originate specifically in aspects of their 'mini' condition: physical isolation, small area and population, etc. For instance, physical isolation and difficulty of communication will normally result in psychological isolation and a lack of knowledge or understanding of the outside world. A population may be so small that it becomes extremely difficult or exorbitantly expensive to establish institutions which would be indispensable in moulding a group into a viable nation. It may be impossible to organize a higher education system if there is not a minimum supply of students, or to set up a diplomatic service if enough people cannot be spared to fill the necessary posts.

An additional difficulty is that such states and territories present a wide variety in status from the point of view of international law. Such entities, when independent, have difficulty in establishing the necessary administrative structures to conduct foreign relations through multilateral diplomacy, particularly through international organizations. Defence and national security give rise to special problems because of the lack of resources. Such territories are often reluctant to encourage the withdrawal of foreign power military bases on which they may depend for security and foreign exchange.

Background

The issue of small states and territories' non-viability gained prominence after decolonization in the mid-20th century, as newly independent microstates faced acute economic, political, and security vulnerabilities. International forums, notably the United Nations, began documenting these challenges in the 1970s, highlighting persistent difficulties in self-sufficiency and resilience. Subsequent global assessments, such as the UN’s 1994 Barbados Programme of Action, further underscored the unique and enduring risks confronting small states and territories worldwide.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Incidence

Small states and territories, often characterized by limited populations, geographic isolation, and restricted resources, face acute challenges in sustaining economic viability and political autonomy. Globally, many such entities struggle to provide essential services, attract investment, and withstand external shocks, making them disproportionately vulnerable to economic downturns, climate change, and geopolitical pressures. Their dependence on larger nations or international aid further exacerbates their precarious position, highlighting the widespread and persistent nature of this issue.
In 2023, the Pacific island nation of Tuvalu faced heightened concerns over its non-viability due to rising sea levels and dwindling freshwater supplies. The government publicly explored options for digital nationhood and potential relocation, underscoring the existential threats confronting small states.
This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Claim

The structural flaw written into the Charter of the United Nations reinforces the cult of the sovereign state and the democratic fallacy of "one state, one vote", whereas democracy can only be based on popular vote. This fallacy encouraged the proliferation of many non-viable states eager for the prestige and perks of UN membership. Membership has risen from 51 states in 1945 to 184 in 1993, with the prospect that if Africa should fragment along ethnic lines the number might rise to 450.

Counter-claim

The so-called "non-viability" of small states and territories is vastly overstated and not an important problem. Many small states thrive, demonstrating resilience, innovation, and strong governance. Their size often enables nimble decision-making and close-knit communities. Globalization and technology have further leveled the playing field. Instead of fixating on their viability, we should recognize their unique strengths and contributions, rather than perpetuating an outdated narrative of weakness or irrelevance.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Broader

Frail states
Yet to rate

Narrower

Military dependency
Unpresentable

Aggravates

Aggravated by

Excessive costs
Unpresentable
Continentalism
Yet to rate

Related

Lack of human unity
Unpresentable

Strategy

Value

Inviability
Yet to rate

Reference

SDG

Sustainable Development Goal #10: Reduced InequalitySustainable Development Goal #16: Peace and Justice Strong Institutions

Metadata

Database
World problems
Type
(D) Detailed problems
Biological classification
N/A
Subject
Content quality
Presentable
 Presentable
Language
English
1A4N
D0441
DOCID
11404410
D7NID
133426
Editing link
Official link
Last update
May 20, 2022