1. World problems
  2. Migrant labour

Migrant labour

  • Guest workers
  • Seasonal workers
  • Reliance on foreign labour

Nature

Many countries increasingly use large numbers of migrant workers, due to the inadequate supply of national labour, the difficulty encountered in filling certain arduous or low paid jobs, or due to the seasonal nature of the work. It is the conditions of work and life of the migrant workers that cause concern. Language difficulties may debar these persons from entering into harmonious human contact and working relationships, leading to social isolation prejudicial to the worker's mental health and safety problems resulting from inability to understand instructions. Provision of satisfactory accommodation is difficult. Families are broken up for the duration of absence or parents and children may keep entirely different working hours, as in the hotel industry. Sometimes the entire nuclear family migrates, in which case links with extended family are weakened. Other times, just the man or woman migrates, leaving behind a family, often with young children -- as in the case with many of the 125,000 Filipina domestic helpers in Hong Kong. Young persons risk mental health problems and delinquency due to the promiscuous manner in which they are thrown together in the absence of parental authority. Workers run medical risks due to diet deficiencies, and they may bring infectious diseases from their country of origin and spread them to the resident population.

Background

Rich countries have always imported labour from poorer ones. In the days of the British Empire, the British imported Tamils and Chinese to work on the plantations and mines of Malaya and Ceylon, Indians to build railways in east Africa and to cut sugar in South Africa. Chinese workers contributed massively to the railroads of the western USA. In the 1960, South Korea began to send coal miners and later nurses to (West) Germany. South Vietnam during the American occupation was another huge labour market for projects out of the firing line. The difference today is not of kind, but of scale and direction. The big Arab oil exporters have grand developmental ambitions but small populations—even Iraq has only 17m people. Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan have needed massive labour forces to continue their rapid economic growth.

Incidence

Pakistani workers abroad sent home more than $16 billion in the ten years to the end of 1986. In 1983 Bengalis working overseas sent back $610m, which is equal to 80% of Bangladesh's merchandise exports and one-quarter of its imports. Filipinos in the same year returned to the Philippines around $950m, which was 3.5% of the GDP. These figures do not include the flourishing black markets and informal arrangements which bypass banking procedures. In 1991, Cuban, Vietnamese and Mozambican guest workers in former East Germany have become the subject of neo-nazi hatred.

Claim

Migrant labour is a critical issue that demands urgent attention. Exploitation, unsafe working conditions, and lack of legal protections plague millions of workers worldwide. These individuals are the backbone of many economies, yet they are often treated as disposable. Ignoring their plight perpetuates injustice and deepens social inequality. We must recognize migrant labour as a pressing problem and take immediate action to ensure fair treatment, dignity, and rights for all workers, regardless of origin.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Counter-claim

The issue of migrant labour is grossly exaggerated and does not warrant the attention it receives. In reality, migrant workers fill essential roles, contribute to economic growth, and adapt quickly to new environments. Claims of crisis are often politically motivated and distract from more pressing societal concerns. Instead of viewing migrant labour as a problem, we should recognize it as a natural and beneficial part of a dynamic, globalized economy.This information has been generated by artificial intelligence.

Broader

Narrower

Aggravates

Xenophobia
Excellent
Statelessness
Presentable
Schistosomiasis
Presentable
Class conflict
Presentable

Aggravated by

Labour shortage
Unpresentable

Reduces

Related

Strategy

Value

Belief-Unbelief
Presentable
Self-reliance
Yet to rate
Reliance
Yet to rate
Overreliance
Yet to rate
Foreign
Yet to rate

SDG

Sustainable Development Goal #8: Decent Work and Economic GrowthSustainable Development Goal #13: Climate ActionSustainable Development Goal #16: Peace and Justice Strong Institutions

Metadata

Database
World problems
Type
(C) Cross-sectoral problems
Biological classification
N/A
Subject
  • Climatology » Climatology
  • Social activity » Work
  • Social activity » Workers
  • Society » Foreign
  • Society » Migrants
  • Content quality
    Presentable
     Presentable
    Language
    English
    1A4N
    C0180
    DOCID
    11301800
    D7NID
    145433
    Editing link
    Official link
    Last update
    May 20, 2022