Divisive roads

Divisive infrastructure patterns

Nature

Divisive roads refer to transportation infrastructure that physically and socially separates communities, often exacerbating inequality and hindering social cohesion. These roads can create barriers to access essential services, limit mobility, and contribute to environmental degradation. Typically found in urban areas, divisive roads may prioritize vehicular traffic over pedestrian and cyclist safety, leading to increased accidents and reduced community interaction. The phenomenon often disproportionately affects marginalized populations, reinforcing existing disparities. Addressing divisive roads involves urban planning strategies that promote connectivity, inclusivity, and sustainable transportation options, fostering a more integrated and equitable urban environment.

Incidence

Divisive roads, often characterized by their role in segregating communities, are prevalent in urban areas worldwide. For instance, in the United States, studies indicate that over 1,000 miles of highways were constructed through predominantly Black neighborhoods during the mid-20th century, contributing to long-lasting socio-economic disparities. Globally, cities like São Paulo and Johannesburg have experienced similar patterns, where major roadways have physically divided communities, impacting access to resources and social cohesion.
A notable example occurred in 2017 in the city of Charlottesville, Virginia, where the proposed removal of the Robert E. Lee statue sparked intense protests and discussions about the divisive nature of roads and monuments. The statue's location on a prominent road became a focal point for debates on race, history, and community identity, illustrating how infrastructure can embody and exacerbate societal divisions.

Claim

We build structures to cross rivers with no consideration for the significance of the river, or for nature's flow. Bridges are species specific made for human use. Cement highways, steel railways, canals, pipelines, powerlines and other infrastructure divide earth into a chaotic, lifeless, trash-covered checkerboard.

Counter-claim

Divisive roads are a trivial concern in the grand scheme of societal issues. While some may argue they create barriers, the real problems lie in poverty, education, and healthcare. Focusing on roads distracts from urgent matters that affect lives daily. Instead of wasting resources on divisive road debates, we should unite to tackle pressing challenges that truly matter. Let’s prioritize what impacts our communities rather than getting bogged down by the inconsequential.